Engineering contexts & challenges · National 5

The systems approach & control

5 cards · 3 quiz · 0 exam
What you're learning in this topic

Learning intention WALT

We are learning about the systems approach & control, specifically to:

know

  • time-based (fixed loop) and sensor-based control

understand

  • the difference between open loop and closed loop control
  • a closed loop control diagram: comparator, controller, driver, output, sensor

be able to

  • draw a universal system diagram (input, process, output) for a given system
  • draw sub-system diagrams, including feedback paths

Success criteria WILF

  • I can draw a universal system diagram (input, process, output) for a given system
  • I can draw sub-system diagrams, including feedback paths
  • I can describe the difference between open loop and closed loop control
  • I can recognise time-based (fixed loop) and sensor-based control
  • I can draw and describe a closed loop control diagram: comparator, controller, driver, output, sensor

Input, process, output

Any system can be shown as a universal system diagram: input → process → output. A sub-system diagram breaks the process into blocks (e.g. sensor → control → driver → motor), with arrows showing the signal or energy passing between them.

In exam diagrams use the general words input, process and output where asked. The 2025 report noted that specific labels such as "user input" or "output energy" scored nothing on a universal system diagram.

InputProcessOutputUniversal system diagramInputControllerDriverOutputOpen loop control: no feedback, so the output is not checkedSet level+−errorControllerDriverOutputSensorfeedbackClosed loop control: the sensor feeds back the actual output
Open loop systems have no feedback: the output is never checked. In closed loop control a sensor measures the actual output and feeds it back; the comparator subtracts it from the set level to give an error, and the controller acts to reduce the error.

Finding inputs and outputs

To fill in a universal system diagram, ask two questions:

  • Input: what do I have to do to make it work? (e.g. switch it on, add fuel, press a button)
  • Output: what does it do? (e.g. hot water, rotary movement, light)

You can also show the energy going in and out: a kettle turns electrical energy into heat (thermal) energy; a car turns chemical energy into kinetic energy.

Sub-system diagrams, boundary and driver

A sub-system diagram breaks the process into parts. Draw a dashed box round it: this is the system boundary. Anything inside is part of the system; anything outside is the outside world (the user, the room).

Most Engineering Science systems follow the same pattern:

  • Control unit: usually an electronic circuit that makes decisions.
  • Driver: amplifies the small signal from the control unit so it can power the output (e.g. a transistor or relay). A driver is always needed before a motor, lamp or heater.
  • Output: usually a motor, lamp or heater.
  • Feedback sensor (closed loop only): usually a light, temperature or speed sensor.

Always draw proper arrowheads to show the direction of each signal.

Open and closed loop control

  • Open loop: no feedback. The system does what it is set to do and doesn't check the result, e.g. a toaster on a timer.
  • Closed loop: a sensor measures the actual output and feeds it back; the controller compares the actual level with the set (desired) level and adjusts the output, e.g. a thermostat-controlled heater.

When describing a closed-loop system, include all three: the sensor measuring the actual output and feeding back; the control sub-system comparing set and actual; and the specific action on the output ("the heater switches on when the temperature is below the set level and off when above"). Write "closed loop control", not just "closed".

Describing a closed loop system: four steps

  1. Say whether it is open or closed loop (most exam systems are automatic and closed loop).
  2. The user sets the required value (the set value, or reference value), e.g. 21 °C, and the system starts producing its output.
  3. The feedback sensor measures the actual value and feeds it back to the control unit.
  4. The control unit compares the actual value with the set value and adjusts the output to match, e.g. switches the heater off when 21 °C is reached.

Name the real sensor and output in the question: "the thermistor measures the room temperature", not just "the sensor". A speedometer only displays speed; a speed sensor measures it.

Design challenge: automatic greenhouse vent

The brief. A garden centre in Perthshire wants roof vents that open when the greenhouse gets too hot and close when it cools.

  1. Draw a universal system diagram for the vent system.
  2. Draw a closed-loop control diagram, labelling the sensor, controller, actuator and feedback.
  3. Describe how the system keeps the temperature near 25 °C.
  4. Suggest one reason a closed-loop system is better here than a timer.
What a good answer includes
  • Input: temperature; process: control; output: vent movement (not component names).
  • A temperature sensor feeding back to a comparator/controller, which drives a motor or cylinder.
  • Use the four steps: set level, sensor measures the actual temperature, compared to give an error, actuator responds.
  • A timer can't respond to the actual temperature, e.g. a cold sunny day.

Key terms

Universal system diagramInput → process → output.
Sub-systemOne block of a system, e.g. sensor, controller, driver, output device.
Open loop controlNo feedback: the output is not checked.
Closed loop controlA sensor feeds back the actual output; the controller compares it with the set level and adjusts.
FeedbackThe signal from the output returned to the input/controller for comparison.

Quick check

1. A toaster that pops up after a fixed time is…

  1. Closed loop
  2. Sensor-controlled
  3. Open loop
  4. Feedback-controlled
Show answer
C: Open loop. No measurement of the toast.

2. In a closed-loop heater, which component measures the actual temperature?

  1. The heater element
  2. The relay contacts
  3. The comparator
  4. Temperature sensor
Show answer
D: Temperature sensor. The sensor feeds back the actual level.

3. On a universal system diagram, the middle block is labelled…

  1. Process
  2. Control
  3. Driver
  4. Sensor
Show answer
A: Process. Input, process, output.

Printable worksheet

An I do, we do, you do worksheet for this topic, with a separate answer sheet.

Worksheet (PDF)Answers (PDF)